MARYLAND STATE HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION 05/07/2018 TABULATION OF BIDS Proposal No: XX3765177 Call Order: 102 Counties: BALTIMORE COUNTY Letting Date: 05/03/2018 12:00 PM District: 4 Contract Time : 12/31/2020 Completion Date Projects: AC-NHPP-000B(249)E Proposal Description: INTERSTATE PATCHING AND RESURFACING AT VARIOUS LOCATIONS IN BALTIMORE COUNTY _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Rank Name Total Bid % Over Low Bid _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 1 GRAY & SON, INC. 8,997,000.00000 100.00 2 P. FLANIGAN & SONS, INC. 9,273,412.50000 103.07 3 C. J. MILLER, LLC. 9,873,821.00000 109.75 _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- LINE NO ITEM CODE ITEM DESCRIPTION | UOM | QUANTITY | GRAY & SON, INC. | P. FLANIGAN & SONS, INC. | C. J. MILLER, LLC. | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- UNIT PRICE | AMOUNT | UNIT PRICE | AMOUNT | UNIT PRICE | AMOUNT | PRELIMINARY 1001 110350 TYPE B ENGINEERS OFFICE | LS | 1.00000 | 1.00000 | 1.00000 | 79,000.00000 | 79,000.00000 | 75,000.00000 | 75,000.00000 | 1002 110500 PRICE ADJUSTMENT FOR DIESEL FUEL | EA | 53,000.00000 | 1.00000 | 53,000.00000 | 1.00000 | 53,000.00000 | 1.00000 | 53,000.00000 | 1003 114006 5 INCH YELLOW PAVEMENT MARKING PAIN | LF | 10,000.00000 | .30000 | 3,000.00000 | 1.50000 | 15,000.00000 | .32000 | 3,200.00000 | 1004 114011 5 INCH WHITE PAVEMENT MARKING PAINT | LF | 20,000.00000 | .30000 | 6,000.00000 | 1.50000 | 30,000.00000 | .32000 | 6,400.00000 | 1005 114216 5 INCH YELLOW REMOVABLE PAVEMENT LI | LF | 2,500.00000 | .88000 | 2,200.00000 | 1.00000 | 2,500.00000 | 1.54000 | 3,850.00000 | 1006 114221 5 INCH WHITE REMOVABLE PAVEMENT LIN | LF | 5,000.00000 | .88000 | 4,400.00000 | 1.00000 | 5,000.00000 | 1.54000 | 7,700.00000 | 1007 114276 REMOVAL OF REMOVABLE PAVEMENT MARKI | LF | 7,500.00000 | .55000 | 4,125.00000 | .10000 | 750.00000 | .34000 | 2,550.00000 | 1008 120510 MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC | UD | 400.00000 | 1,355.00000 | 542,000.00000 | 1,600.00000 | 640,000.00000 | 6,000.00000 | 2,400,000.00000 | 1009 120555 GRADED AGGREGATE BASE FOR MAINTENAN | TON | 100.00000 | 17.90000 | 1,790.00000 | 15.00000 | 1,500.00000 | .01000 | 1.00000 | 1010 120562 ASPHALT FOR MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC | TON | 300.00000 | 65.75000 | 19,725.00000 | 180.00000 | 54,000.00000 | .01000 | 3.00000 | 1011 120610 ARROW PANEL | UD | 400.00000 | 30.75000 | 12,300.00000 | 5.00000 | 2,000.00000 | 25.00000 | 10,000.00000 | 1012 120625 TEMPORARY TRAFFIC SIGNS HIGH PERFOR | SF | 2,000.00000 | 9.75000 | 19,500.00000 | 11.50000 | 23,000.00000 | 9.00000 | 18,000.00000 | 1013 120820 DRUMS FOR MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC | EA | 200.00000 | .01000 | 2.00000 | 28.00000 | 5,600.00000 | 70.00000 | 14,000.00000 | 1014 120860 PORTABLE VARIABLE MESSAGE SIGN | UD | 200.00000 | 119.50000 | 23,900.00000 | 70.00000 | 14,000.00000 | 130.00000 | 26,000.00000 | 1015 120890 PROTECTION VEHICLE | UD | 400.00000 | .01000 | 4.00000 | 400.00000 | 160,000.00000 | 300.00000 | 120,000.00000 | 1016 130840 CONSTRUCTION STAKEOUT | LS | 1.00000 | 5,130.00000 | 5,130.00000 | 14,000.00000 | 14,000.00000 | 25,000.00000 | 25,000.00000 | 1017 130850 MOBILIZATION | LS | 1.00000 | 256,953.00000 | 256,953.00000 | 700,000.00000 | 700,000.00000 | 287,587.00000 | 287,587.00000 | PRELIMINARY ITEMS TOTAL : | 954,030.00000 | 1,799,350.00000 | 3,052,291.00000 | DRAINAGE 3001 387106 6 INCH PERFORATED CIRCULAR PIPE LON | LF | 200.00000 | 20.00000 | 4,000.00000 | 25.00000 | 5,000.00000 | 10.00000 | 2,000.00000 | 3002 387109 6 INCH CIRCULAR PIPE UNDERDRAIN OUT | LF | 100.00000 | 32.75000 | 3,275.00000 | 25.00000 | 2,500.00000 | 10.00000 | 1,000.00000 | DRAINAGE ITEMS TOTAL : | 7,275.00000 | 7,500.00000 | 3,000.00000 | PAVING 5001 500000-EA . DOWEL BAR RETROFIT | EA | 250.00000 | 1,025.00000 | 256,250.00000 | 400.00000 | 100,000.00000 | 825.00000 | 206,250.00000 | 5002 500000-SY . DIAMOND GRINDING | SY | 15,000.00000 | 5.15000 | 77,250.00000 | 7.00000 | 105,000.00000 | 1.76000 | 26,400.00000 | 5003 500000-SY . FINE MILLING ASPHALT PAVEMENT (0- | SY | 5,000.00000 | 2.25000 | 11,250.00000 | 4.25000 | 21,250.00000 | 1.80000 | 9,000.00000 | 5004 500000-SY . FINE MILLING ASPHALT PAVEMENT (1- | SY | 200,000.00000 | 2.50000 | 500,000.00000 | 2.80000 | 560,000.00000 | 1.42000 | 284,000.00000 | 5005 500000-SY . STANDARD MILLING ASPHALT PAVEMENT | SY | 4,000.00000 | 6.50000 | 26,000.00000 | 6.50000 | 26,000.00000 | 2.35000 | 9,400.00000 | 5006 504512 SUPERPAVE ASPHALT MIX 9.5MM FOR SUR | TON | 3,000.00000 | 78.25000 | 234,750.00000 | 85.00000 | 255,000.00000 | 78.00000 | 234,000.00000 | 5007 504545 GAP-GRADED ASPHALT MIX 12.5MM FOR S | TON | 20,000.00000 | 102.50000 | 2,050,000.00000 | 102.00000 | 2,040,000.00000 | 94.00000 | 1,880,000.00000 | 5008 504564 SUPERPAVE ASPHALT MIX 19.0MM FOR FU | TON | 3,500.00000 | 165.00000 | 577,500.00000 | 145.00000 | 507,500.00000 | 93.00000 | 325,500.00000 | 5009 504568 SUPERPAVE ASPHALT MIX 19.0MM FOR PA | TON | 10,000.00000 | 143.85000 | 1,438,500.00000 | 150.00000 | 1,500,000.00000 | 93.00000 | 930,000.00000 | 5010 504600 PRICE ADJUSTMENT FOR ASPHALT BINDER | EA | 103,000.00000 | 1.00000 | 103,000.00000 | 1.00000 | 103,000.00000 | 1.00000 | 103,000.00000 | 5011 504605 PAYMENT ADJUSTMENT FOR PAVEMENT DEN | EA | 136,850.00000 | 1.00000 | 136,850.00000 | 1.00000 | 136,850.00000 | 1.00000 | 136,850.00000 | 5012 504615 PAYMENT ADJUSTMENT FOR ASPHALT MIXT | EA | 136,850.00000 | 1.00000 | 136,850.00000 | 1.00000 | 136,850.00000 | 1.00000 | 136,850.00000 | 5013 520113 6 INCH GRADED AGGREGATE BASE COURSE | SY | 200.00000 | 21.50000 | 4,300.00000 | 15.00000 | 3,000.00000 | 14.00000 | 2,800.00000 | 5014 535100 PAVEMENT SURFACE PROFILE PAY ADJUST | EA | 100,000.00000 | 1.00000 | 100,000.00000 | 1.00000 | 100,000.00000 | 1.00000 | 100,000.00000 | 5015 549101 5 INCH WHITE CONTRAST PAVEMENT MARK | LF | 1,000.00000 | 7.15000 | 7,150.00000 | 6.40000 | 6,400.00000 | 7.68000 | 7,680.00000 | 5016 549103 5 INCH YELLOW CONTRAST PAVEMENT MAR | LF | 1,000.00000 | 7.15000 | 7,150.00000 | 6.40000 | 6,400.00000 | 7.68000 | 7,680.00000 | 5017 549201 5 INCH WHITE INLAID PAVEMENT MARKIN | LF | 60,000.00000 | 3.25000 | 195,000.00000 | 3.30000 | 198,000.00000 | 3.52000 | 211,200.00000 | 5018 549203 5 INCH YELLOW INLAID PAVEMENT MARKI | LF | 30,000.00000 | 3.25000 | 97,500.00000 | 3.10000 | 93,000.00000 | 3.52000 | 105,600.00000 | 5019 549205 10 INCH WHITE INLAID PAVEMENT MARKI | LF | 2,000.00000 | 6.15000 | 12,300.00000 | 5.55000 | 11,100.00000 | 6.60000 | 13,200.00000 | 5020 549401 5 INCH WHITE THERMOPLASTIC PAVEMENT | LF | 6,000.00000 | .91000 | 5,460.00000 | .95000 | 5,700.00000 | .98000 | 5,880.00000 | 5021 549403 5 INCH YELLOW THERMOPLASTIC PAVEMEN | LF | 3,500.00000 | .91000 | 3,185.00000 | .95000 | 3,325.00000 | .94000 | 3,290.00000 | 5022 549620 WHITE PREFORMED THERMOPLASTIC PAVEM | SF | 1,175.00000 | 20.00000 | 23,500.00000 | 20.50000 | 24,087.50000 | 22.00000 | 25,850.00000 | 5023 549720 RECESSED SNOWPLOWABLE RAISED PAVEME | EA | 400.00000 | 32.25000 | 12,900.00000 | 31.00000 | 12,400.00000 | 33.00000 | 13,200.00000 | 5024 549724 RECESSED SNOWPLOWABLE RAISED PAVEME | EA | 1,800.00000 | 35.00000 | 63,000.00000 | 39.00000 | 70,200.00000 | 36.00000 | 64,800.00000 | 5025 571035 CONTINUOUSLY REINFORCED PORTLAND CE | SY | 400.00000 | 342.50000 | 137,000.00000 | 240.00000 | 96,000.00000 | 294.00000 | 117,600.00000 | 5026 571040 CONTINUOUSLY REINFORCED PORTLAND CE | SY | 600.00000 | 342.50000 | 205,500.00000 | 240.00000 | 144,000.00000 | 284.00000 | 170,400.00000 | 5027 571050 PORTLAND CEMENT CONCRETE PAVEMENT R | SY | 1,000.00000 | 303.70000 | 303,700.00000 | 240.00000 | 240,000.00000 | 268.00000 | 268,000.00000 | 5028 571055 PORTLAND CEMENT CONCRETE PAVEMENT R | SY | 1,000.00000 | 303.70000 | 303,700.00000 | 240.00000 | 240,000.00000 | 258.00000 | 258,000.00000 | 5029 571075 PORTLAND CEMENT CONCRETE SPALL REPA | SY | 1,250.00000 | 564.00000 | 705,000.00000 | 350.00000 | 437,500.00000 | 594.00000 | 742,500.00000 | 5030 571116 JOINT SEALING OF PORTLAND CEMENT CO | LF | 50,000.00000 | 1.82000 | 91,000.00000 | 2.00000 | 100,000.00000 | 5.55000 | 277,500.00000 | 5031 571160 CRACK SEALER | LF | 15,000.00000 | 1.56000 | 23,400.00000 | 2.00000 | 30,000.00000 | 2.00000 | 30,000.00000 | 5032 571165 ASPHALT REPAIR MASTIC | LB | 1,200.00000 | 11.50000 | 13,800.00000 | 10.00000 | 12,000.00000 | 12.00000 | 14,400.00000 | 5033 571205 REMOVAL OF UNSUITABLE MATERIAL AND | CY | 500.00000 | 66.00000 | 33,000.00000 | 25.00000 | 12,500.00000 | 45.00000 | 22,500.00000 | 5034 571300 RUMBLE STRIPS | LF | 10,000.00000 | 1.25000 | 12,500.00000 | 2.05000 | 20,500.00000 | .40000 | 4,000.00000 | 5035 599160 SUPERPAVE ASPHALT MIX 12.5MM FOR BR | TON | 500.00000 | 227.50000 | 113,750.00000 | 185.00000 | 92,500.00000 | 120.00000 | 60,000.00000 | PAVING ITEMS TOTAL : | 8,021,995.00000 | 7,450,062.50000 | 6,807,330.00000 | SHOULDERS 6001 616250 CRUSHER RUN AGGREGATE CR-6 FOR SHOU | TON | 300.00000 | 27.00000 | 8,100.00000 | 35.00000 | 10,500.00000 | 24.00000 | 7,200.00000 | 6002 616605 ASPHALT MILLINGS OR GRINDINGS FOR S | TON | 200.00000 | 28.00000 | 5,600.00000 | 30.00000 | 6,000.00000 | 20.00000 | 4,000.00000 | SHOULDERS ITEMS TOTAL : | 13,700.00000 | 16,500.00000 | 11,200.00000 | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Vendor Total Bid : 8,997,000.00000 | 9,273,412.50000 | 9,873,821.00000 | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------